What was America’s original form of democratic government

Here is my essay of your question,

I often hear people argue that the United States is a republic, not a democracy. But that’s a false dichotomy. A common definition of “republic” is, to quote the American Heritage Dictionary, “A political order in which the supreme power lies in a body of citizens who are entitled to vote for officers and representatives responsible to them” — we are that. A common definition of “democracy” is, “Government by the people, exercised either directly or through elected representatives” — we are that, too.

Support our journalism. Subscribe today.

The United States is not a direct democracy, in the sense of a country in which laws (and other government decisions) are made predominantly by majority vote. Some lawmaking is done this way, on the state and local levels, but it’s only a tiny fraction of all lawmaking. But we are a representative democracy, which is a form of democracy.

And indeed the American form of government has been called a “democracy” by leading American statesmen and legal commentators from the Framing on. It’s true that some Framing-era commentators made arguments that distinguished “democracy” and “republic”; see, for instance, The Federalist (No. 10), though even that first draws the distinction between “pure democracy” and a “republic,” only later just saying “democracy.” But even in that era, “representative democracy” was understood as a form of democracy, alongside “pure democracy”: John Adams used the term “representative democracy” in 1794; so did Noah Webster in 1785; so did St. George Tucker in his 1803 edition of Blackstone; so did Thomas Jefferson in 1815. Tucker’s Blackstone likewise uses “democracy” to describe a representative democracy, even when the qualifier “representative” is omitted.

Likewise, James Wilson, one of the main drafters of the Constitution and one of the first Supreme Court Justices, defended the Constitution in 1787 by speaking of the three forms of government being the “monarchical, aristocratical, and democratical,” and said that in a democracy the sovereign power is “inherent in the people, and is either exercised by themselves or by their representatives.” And Chief Justice John Marshall — who helped lead the fight in the 1788 Virginia Convention for ratifying the U.S. Constitution — likewise defended the Constitution in that convention by describing it as implementing “democracy” (as opposed to “despotism”), and without the need to even add the qualifier “representative.”

To be sure, in addition to being a representative democracy, the United States is also a constitutional democracy, in which courts restrain in some measure the democratic will. And the United States is therefore also a constitutional republic. Indeed, the United States might be labeled a constitutional federal representative democracy. But where one word is used, with all the oversimplification that this necessary entails, “democracy” and “republic” both work. Indeed, since direct democracy — again, a government in which all or most laws are made by direct popular vote — would be impractical given the number and complexity of laws that pretty much any state or national government is expected to enact, it’s unsurprising that the qualifier “representative” would often be omitted. Practically speaking, representative democracy is the only democracy that’s around at any state or national level.

Now one can certainly argue that some aspects of U.S. government should become less direct, and filtered through more layers of representation. One can argue, for instance, that the 17th Amendment should be repealed, and that U.S. senators should no longer be elected directly by the people, but should return to being elected by state legislators who are elected by the people. Or one can argue for repealing state- and local-level initiative and referendum schemes. Or one can argue for making the Electoral College into a deliberative body, in which the electors are supposed to discuss the candidates and make various political deals, rather than being elected solely to vote for particular candidates. And of course one can equally argue for making some aspects of U.S. government more direct, for instance by shifting to truly direct election of the president, or by institute a federal-level initiative and referendum.

But there is no basis for saying that the United States is somehow “not a democracy, but a republic.” “Democracy” and “republic” aren’t just words that a speaker can arbitrarily define to mean something (e.g., defining democracy as “a form of government in which all laws are made directly by the people”). They are terms that have been given meaning by English speakers more broadly. And both today and in the Framing era, “democracy” has been generally understood to include representative democracy as well as direct democracy.

PLEAS HELP QUICKLY: (FIRST ANSWER GETS BRAINLIEST!)

Why was keeping peace with the British important to the United States?


A) America needed British protection from France.



B) The United States was already at war with France.



C) The United States depended on imported goods from Great Britain.

Growing urban population provided:

A. Cheap labor and markets for new products

B. Experience slavery and unions

C. Cheap labor and unions

D. Experienced labor and markets for new products

how is congressional power to control acts of war and treaties with foreign countries solidified in clause 3

HELP ASAP WILL GIVE CROWN

To describe god as one is best way to understand god “evaluate this statement”

Why did New France Develop slowly?

Why is the seven years War describes as one of the most important wars in modern history?

True or False: The majority of Arab people are found in Southwest Asia
and northern Africa.

Which of the following best describes the area where Clovis sites have been found?
O throughout Canada and Mexico
O throughout the United States
O from northern Canada to southern Mexico
O from southern Canada to northern Mexico

Why was the battle of Yorktown successful?

The French military aid
The assistance of all European powers
The military might of Washington and his troops
The superior numbers of Americans ​

Identify Main Idea What is the most important feature of a democracy?

do you still remember the 3G's?​

Do anyone think that Donald trump shouldn’t be the president Of u.s.a due to his bad impression of white and black peoples

Which statement accurately compares the process of industrialization in
Great Britain and China?
O A. British industrialization was led by private companies, while
Chinese industrialization was led by the government.
B. British industrialization resulted in equal rights for women, while
Chinese industrialization limited women's rights.
O C. British industrialization improved economic productivity, while
industrialization harmed China's economy.
O D. British industrialization took place in urban centers, while Chinese
industrialization was mostly rural.

Why is source for Document A is both reliable and unreliable. Jamestown & the Starving Time

plsss help me i need the answer plssss il give yo 15 ponts

i need asap i will mark brainliest

The Code of Hammurabi, the Twelve Tables, and the
Justinian Code are examples of

Why did Lincoln think Andrew Johnson would be a good choice as Vice-President?​

y was the civil war caused

What’s the difference between the speaker of the house and the senate majority leader?

13. Which of the following is not a major island in Europe?
Iceland
Denmark
O
Great Britain
Ireland
14. In which region does most of Europes agricultural activity take place?

7.
What techniques did ancient Egyptians use to make their farming
more
productive?

How did the United States respond to the Soviet blockade of West Berlin in 1948?

options

The United States declared war on The Soviet Union.


The United States let the Soviets take West Berlin.


The United States airlifted tons of material to keep the city going.


The United States declared war on East Germany.

PLEASE HELP ILL MARK YOU BRAINLYEST IF RIGTH!!
According to Article I of the Constitution, the legislative branch is made up of
the House and the Senate.
federal agencies and the framers.
local courts and the Supreme Court.
Congress and the military.

Before Jesus died, He was identified by the voce from Heaven as the Lamb. What verse early in John's gospel says so?

what is meant by decentralization of powers in india
​

List three rights that the colonists stated they had or should have as part of the Stamp Act Congress.

what would you do if you always get blamed for things even though you didnt do it and you try to tell them but they just wont listen should i just sit back and listen to it or should i run away

Which sources would be considered reliable? Check all that apply. A. student's assignment B. an article from a referred journal C. a personal website D. a university website E. an online editorial about an issue F. a government website​

At the end of the Civil War, Lincoln faced tremendous challenges, as did newly freed Black people seeking a way to fend for themselves in their new situation: trying to earn a living, buy or lease property on which to do it, and protect themselves and their families from the brutalities of vengeful former slave owners. Read the brief correspondences identifying these needs and challenges, and write a brief personal response.